The investigation itself is weird as much as his motives are unclear. Basically, he only interviews three people and then (in a 30-page long scene!) that other PI more or less explains everything our main man McNee needs to know about the story. You know - stuff from the past that detectives are usually supposed to uncover themselves... But then again, this is not such a bad thing since otherwise, this book would probably be 1000 pages long instead of "just" 300.
Yes - 300 pages. It does take its time. Moves slowly, constantly going back into the past... with the body count counter remaining still... taking its time to tell the reader a thing or two about the local history... and architecture... and - worst of all! - with our hero constantly whining and feeling sorry for himself.
Surprisingly it still works pretty well. I wouldn't say it is a page-turner, but it's definitely not dull. It is skillfully written, and although the pace is slow, it has a nice rhythm. Dialogues are smart, and they contain a decent dosage of the local slang (although it rarely goes beyond the usual Scottish wee, lass, aye, shite stuff). For my taste, there's a bit too much of the psychological/philosophical crap, but at the same time, I didn't find it pretensions at all. And to be (a wee) pretentious myself, I'll conclude by saying that McLean maybe tried too hard to create something extraordinary and lost focus on the story along the way.
Interesting and honest writing but simply not hard-boiled enough for me.
3/5
Facts:
Hero:
PI McNee
She looked at the card. Said, "Who're you trying to fool? Nobody's a private investigator. Not in Dundee of all places."
"You're a man with a conscience and a code and all that other bollocks, but you're also a man who drags his own disaster around with him like a wrecking ball. You want to help people. But you can't. Can't even help your fucking self."
The psychiatrist... had unofficially diagnosed me like this:
"You have to be the hero. Save everyone. Doesn't matter if you know it's bad idea. It's a compulsion. To satisfy your own ego."
I'd called shite.
Location:
Dundee was Scotland's fourth city in terms of size, constantly jockeying with Aberdeen for the coveted position of third. But its reputation as the city with the small town feel was what gave it the edge.
Dundee was Scotland's fourth city in terms of size, constantly jockeying with Aberdeen for the coveted position of third. But its reputation as the city with the small town feel was what gave it the edge.
Body
count: 2
Dames:
Mary Furst is 14 years old, and both sisters are a mess, so none of them exactly qualifies as "dame"
Blackouts:
Couldn't hear the words. Couldn't hear the voices. My face was on fire, pain searing up and along my cheekbones.
Finally, I blacked out.
Call that a mercy.
Mary Furst is 14 years old, and both sisters are a mess, so none of them exactly qualifies as "dame"
Blackouts:
Couldn't hear the words. Couldn't hear the voices. My face was on fire, pain searing up and along my cheekbones.
Finally, I blacked out.
Call that a mercy.
Title:
The kettle boiled. The switch clicked.
The idea slipped into focus.
The sister.
Edition: Five Leaves Publications, 2009. Signed!
Cover:
Looks like a fucking computer manual. When I see such plain covers, I often think of authors and how shitty they must feel about their publishers investing fuck all in the cover art. Long live the Hard Case Crime!
The kettle boiled. The switch clicked.
The idea slipped into focus.
The sister.
Edition: Five Leaves Publications, 2009. Signed!
Cover:
Looks like a fucking computer manual. When I see such plain covers, I often think of authors and how shitty they must feel about their publishers investing fuck all in the cover art. Long live the Hard Case Crime!
Cool lines: /
